Hearings

January 6, 2011

Full Committee

H.R. 2 — Repealing the Job-Killing Health Care Law and H.Res. 9 — Instructing certain committees to report legislation replacing the job-killing health care law

H-313 The Capitol
Multimedia Link


Meeting Information:

Meeting Time: Thursday, January 6, 2011 at 3:00 PM in H-313 The Capitol 

To watch this hearing, click here

 

Related Legislation

 Rules Committee Votes:

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 3
Motion by Dr. Foxx: to report rule for H. Res. 9. Adopted: 7-3

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Mr. Sessions……….
Yea
Ms. Slaughter……..
Nay
Ms. Foxx…………….
Yea
Mr. McGovern…….
Nay
Mr. Woodall……….
Yea
Mr. Polis…………….
Nay
Mr. Nugent………..
Yea
 
 
Mr. Scott……………
Yea
 
 
Mr. Webster……….
Yea
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Yea
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 4
Motion by Ms. Slaughter: Motion that the rule be amended to strike the Cantor Amendment. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 5
Motion by Ms. Slaughter: Motion to report an open rule. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 6
Motion by Ms. Slaughter: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Tsongas (MA) et al. #15,, which would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not permit insurance companies to discriminate against women. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 


RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 7
Motion by Ms. Slaughter: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Sanchez (CA) et al., #16, would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not permit insurance companies to rescind an individual's health coverage due to illness or impose annual and lifetime limits, as prohibited under the Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 8
Motion by Mr. McGovern: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Edwards (MD) and Rep. Engel (NY), #26, which would state repeal of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act shall not take effect unless and until the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, in consultation with the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, certifies to the Congress that the repeals effected by such section will not restore the ability of insurance companies to impose unreasonable premium increases as protected against under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 9
Motion by Mr. McGovern: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Tierney (MA) et al. #27, which would state repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect unless and until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not restore the ability of insurance companies to divert premium dollars from patients into insurance company profits and executive perks as prohibited under section 1001 of the Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6
 

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 10
Motion by Mr. McGovern: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Castor (FL) et al. #14, which would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not permit insurance companies to deny coverage to individuals due to a pre-existing condition, as prohibited under the Affordable Care Act.. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 11
Motion by Mr. McGovern: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Larsen (WA) et al. #17, which would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not eliminate health insurance coverage for young adults under 26 who are otherwise eligible for coverage under their parents plan as a result of the Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 12
Motion by Mr. Hastings of Florida: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Thompson (MS) et al. #23, which would state that repealing the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act shall not take effect unless and until the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, in consultation with the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, certifies to the Congress that the repeals effected by such section will not undermine access to primary care. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 13
Motion by Mr. Hastings of Florida: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Deutch (FL) et al., #20, which would state that the Repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not imperil Medicare and raise costs on seniors. Specifically, repeal will not: (a) raise drug costs to seniors and people with disabilities by re-opening the Medicare prescription drug donut hole; (b) eliminate free preventive health coverage; or (c) increase the incidence of fraud and abuse. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 14
Motion by Mr. Hastings of Florida: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Van Hollen (MD) et al., #18 which would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not increase the deficit by eliminating the $230B over 10 years and $1.2T over 20 years in deficit savings achieved by the Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 15
Motion by Mr. Polis: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Peters (MI) et al., #19, which would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not increase taxes on small business offering health insurance, including through the elimination of any tax credit as provided under the Affordable Care Act and will not increase costs for employers offering retiree benefits by eliminating the assistance provided to them under the Affordable Care Act to help maintain retiree health care benefits. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 16
Motion by Mr. Polis: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Heinrich (NM) et al., #22, which would state that repealing the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act shall not take effect unless and until the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, in consultation with the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, certifies to the Congress that the repeals effected by such section will not shorten the life of the Federal Hospital Insurance Trust Fund, which the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act extended by 12 years. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 17
Motion by Mr. Polis: To make in order and provide appropriate waivers for an amendment by Rep. Welch (VT) et al, #21, would state that repeal of the Affordable Care Act shall not take effect until the date upon which CBO certifies that repeal will not increase cost sharing or otherwise reduce access to preventive health benefits such as mammograms, colonoscopies, and diabetes screenings, including such benefits offered by private health plans or by Medicare provided by sections 1001 and 4104 of the Affordable Care Act. Defeated: 4-6

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Nay
Ms. Slaughter……..
Yea
Mr. Woodall……….
Nay
Mr. McGovern…….
Yea
Mr. Nugent………..
Nay
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Yea
Mr. Scott……………
Nay
Mr. Polis…………….
Yea
Mr. Webster……….
Nay
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Nay
 
 

 
RULES COMMITTTEE RECORD VOTE NO. 18
Motion by Dr. Foxx: To report the rule. Adopted: 6-4

Majority Members
Vote
Minority Members
Vote
Ms. Foxx…………….
Yea
Ms. Slaughter……..
Nay
Mr. Woodall……….
Yea
Mr. McGovern…….
Nay
Mr. Nugent………..
Yea
Mr. Hastings (FL)..
Nay
Mr. Scott……………
Yea
Mr. Polis…………….
Nay
Mr. Webster……….
Yea
 
 
Mr. Dreier,    Chairman
Yea